The St. Regis Longboat Key: Our Take

The St. Regis Longboat Key Resort sits right on the Gulf, on Longboat Key near Sarasota, and it is an amazing property. We stayed in September, in the shoulder season, and the honest summary is this: it feels like going to the Caribbean or Hawaii without leaving Florida. The beach, the food, the spa, the pools. This one gets almost everything right.

The Food

The food is exceptional, and there are multiple restaurants, so you can eat somewhere different every night without leaving the resort.

Start with Oshen, the rooftop sushi restaurant. It is phenomenal. The spicy tuna roll is out of this world, and we do not say that lightly.

The Italian restaurant, Riva, is outstanding. The food is very, very good. Riva is also where breakfast happens, and the lobster eggs Benedict in the morning is out of this world. If you like lobster and you like eggs Benedict, it is a must try.

Now the honest note. CW Prime, the high-end steakhouse, is OK. It is not bad. We are just not sure it is worth the money. There are better options on the island if you feel like going out. If you do not feel like traveling, it is a good choice and you will eat well. The wine is very good, with a strong selection.

The Piano Bar

At night, go to The St. Regis Bar. The piano bar is fantastic. It is lively, it is beautiful, and it gives the whole resort a pulse after dinner. A lot of resorts go quiet at night. This one does not.

The Pools

The pool scene is phenomenal. The main pool is beautiful, and the lazy river is very, very nice.

There is an adults-only pool as well, and it is very nice, with one tradeoff: the waterfall there is loud, and that can get a little annoying if quiet is the whole point. If you want to relax without kids around, though, that is the place to be.

A fair caveat: we were there in September, in the shoulder season, and there were not a lot of people around. We cannot tell you how busy the pools get in season. Our guess is that if the lazy river fills up with kids, the adults-only pool becomes the escape, waterfall and all.

The Lagoon

The big lagoon is a showpiece, and it is fun just to watch. For kids, there is an activity where they can get into the lagoon and swim with the stingrays, which is the kind of thing they will talk about for a long time.

The Beach

The beach is gorgeous. Longboat Key beaches are just beautiful, and the sunsets are beautiful. This is a big part of why the resort feels like the Caribbean or Hawaii. The Gulf does the heavy lifting.

Sunset on the beach at Longboat Key.

The Rooms

The rooms are very spacious. We stayed in a king ocean view room in the main tower, and here is the tip that matters: within that same room category, ask for an upper floor and ask to be as close to the water as possible. We were on the third floor, and the fourth or fifth floor would have been better. Same category, same room. You just have to ask.

There are two view choices in the category. One side faces the sunset, which is the side we stayed on. The other faces the pool and the ocean, which is where our friends stayed, and we believe that pool view is the upgraded view and costs a little more. Honestly, we like the sunset view, which is why we picked it. Both are very nice. It really comes down to preference.

The Spa

The spa is out of this world. One of the best spas we have been to, anywhere. Here is the endorsement that says it best: we have been to this spa something like fifteen times now, including trips when we were not even staying at the resort. It is a place we plan around.

Our Take

This resort is just phenomenal, and we recommend it without much hesitation. Come for the food, stay for the spa, and spend your days between the lazy river and one of the prettiest beaches in Florida. Book an upper floor, order the spicy tuna roll and the lobster eggs Benedict, and manage your expectations only at the steakhouse, where the island gives it real competition.

Leave a Comment